- Posted by: abnormalreturns, December 12th, 2013 at 3:52 pm
Sometimes you need to take an idea to its illogical end to show you the absurdity of it. For quite some time now I have been writing about the proliferation of ETFs, or the “ETFization of everything.” Which on the whole has been a boon for investors. However the ETF is still happy to create products based on hot trends or a favorable backtest.
Joel Dickson at Vanguard Advisor did a little data exercise creating “AlphaBet portfolios” that in a backtest showed uniform outperformance relative to the S&P 500 over a ten year period. The only hitch is that the strategy being used, an alphabetical one by ticker symbol, should have no bearing on price performance.
Source: Vanguard Advisor
Dickson rightly notes that the outperformance of these portfolios was driven by the inherent small cap bias of this strategy over this time period. He also notes that narrowly constructed indices and favorable historical backtests are designed to “anchor expectations for future performance.” Investors therefore need to look at this kind of marketing data with a jaundiced eye.
John Rekenthaler at Morningstar recently noted that the wave of so-called “smart beta” products is simply driven by weightings toward small caps and value. Neither of which are either new or particularly novel. History has been kind to both of these factors but investors should go into any investment with an understanding of the drivers of future fund performance in mind.
“Gimmicky ETFs” are nothing new. The above exercise is a good one because it highlights how even a patently absurd strategy can in a backtest look perfectly profitable. Investors therefore need to arm themselves with the knowledge to understand the construction of new and prospective ETFs. In short, just because some firm can put something into an ETF wrapper does not mean that you shouldn’t take a closer look.
Update: The Attain Capital blog had a good post up last month on the “hard issues” facing anyone dealing with backtested results.
Subscribe to our RSS FeedThe Latest
Thursday links: losing money just the same
abnormalreturns, December 12th, 2013 at 12:31 pm
‘Tis the season. Marc Levinson’s The Box: How the Shipping Container Made the World Smaller and the World Economy Bigger ended up on Bill Gates’ […]
Wednesday links: not all risks
abnormalreturns, December 11th, 2013 at 12:51 pm
You can keep up with all of our posts by signing up for our daily e-mail. Thousands of other readers already have. Don’t miss out! […]
The small act of kindness holiday book giveaway
abnormalreturns, December 11th, 2013 at 11:39 am
We here at Abnormal Returns HQ have come into possession of five brand new copies of Abnormal Returns: Winning Strategies from the Frontlines of the […]
Tuesday links: bad portfolio eggs
abnormalreturns, December 10th, 2013 at 12:52 pm
‘Tis the season. Your smart home needs a “smart hub.” Check out a review of Revolv a smart home automation solution over at TechCrunch. Quote […]
Monday links: changing views of art
abnormalreturns, December 9th, 2013 at 11:44 am
‘Tis the season. Ben Carlson at A Wealth of Common Sense ranks Abnormal Returns: Winning Strategies from the Frontlines of the Investment Blogosphere as one […]
Sunday links: history of bubbles
abnormalreturns, December 8th, 2013 at 8:25 am
‘Tis the season: the Daniel Kahneman classic Thinking Fast and Slow is on sale for the Kindle. Quote of the day Morgan Housel, “If the […]
Top clicks this week on Abnormal Returns
abnormalreturns, December 8th, 2013 at 7:03 am
Thanks for checking in with us this weekend. Here are the items our readers clicked most frequently on Abnormal Returns for the week ended Saturday, […]
Saturday links: nothing new under the sun
abnormalreturns, December 7th, 2013 at 7:15 am
‘Tis the season and for the budding entrepreneur on your list check out Hatching Twitter: A True Story of Money, Power, Friendship and Betrayal by […]
Friday links: stop doing things
abnormalreturns, December 6th, 2013 at 12:54 pm
‘Tis the season: Amazon Smile is giving $20 to your favorite charity when you buy a Kindle Fire HDX during the next week. Quote of […]
Abnormal Returns has over its seven-year life become a fixture in the financial blogosphere. Over thousands of posts we have striven to bring the best of the financial blogosphere to readers. In that time the idea of a “forecast-free investment blog” remains as useful as it did six years ago. More »
- Beware backtests built to anchor expectations
- Thursday links: losing money just the same
- Wednesday links: not all risks
- The small act of kindness holiday book giveaway
- Tuesday links: bad portfolio eggs
- Monday links: changing views of art
- Sunday links: history of bubbles
- Top clicks this week on Abnormal Returns
- Saturday links: nothing new under the sun
- Friday links: stop doing things