“Only two things are important right now in life: fertility and deep learning. Everything else is noise. Once you start thinking about these, it’s hard to start thinking about anything else.” – Jesús Fernández-Villaverde
Derek Thompson recently raised a fuss with his Plain English podcast with Fernández-Villaverde who dramatically laid out the potential downsides of rapid, global demographic decline.
When you think about there are few issues that you can honestly say affect everyone on Earth and one of them is demographics. Unlike other economic and financial data points demographic trends typically move pretty slowly. However there is a growing appreciation that global demographics are trending towards slower population growth and a rapidly aging population.
Researchers are looking for reasons why the world has collectively decided to start having fewer babies. Some blame falling interest in organized religion. One recent paper even traced the introduction of the iPhone to lower (teen) pregnancy rates, although there is plenty of room for skepticism on that claim. In the U.S. the falling population growth rate is being blamed, in part, for the acceleration in the underfunding of Social Security.
While we are focused on the U.S., but to be clear this is a global phenomenon. John Burn-Murdoch in the FT has a long piece up looking the (almost) synchronous fall in birth rates around the globe. He is the camp that the introduction of digital media is one factor affecting fertility. No matter the explanation, the world is aging:
In more than two-thirds of the world’s 195 countries, the average number of children born to each woman has fallen below the “replacement rate” of 2.1 that keeps populations stable without immigration. In 66 countries, the average is now closer to one than to two. In some, the most common number of children born to each woman is zero.
We have already seen the impact of demographics in Japan where the country has lost some 3 million people over the past five years. Outside of greater Tokyo, Japan is losing population and some small towns have effectively been abandoned. It’s not just developed countries like Japan and the UK that are seeing a rapid demographic transition. An developing country like India is now already below replacement rate.
Not everything is horrible. One could argue that slowing global population growth would make it easier to deal with our many environmental challenges. The flip side is that people are living longer. Global life expectancy, after a Covid blip, continues to expand. From a Goldman Sachs research report:
While it is right to focus on the economic implications of a transition of this importance, economists should not lose sight of the fact that increasing life expectancy is a fundamentally positive development. In addition to living longer, people are also living healthier lives, in the sense that the functional capacity of older individuals is improving over time.
One of the ironies is that while demographics are collapsing many countries are turning against immigration. Switzerland is voting on a referendum to cap the number of people in the country. Over the past eighteen months, net migration to the U.S. has hit a wall. Jerusalem Demsas at The Argument writes:
It is a demographic fact that the United States, without immigration, will begin to shrink, and the ratio between old and young will grow increasingly unbalanced. Such a development will make social services increasingly hard to pay for, reduce the innovative capacity of the United States, and bias our politics even more toward short-termism and low-risk decision-making.
There are a number of ways an aging population will play out beyond Social Security. The workforce will have to adjust to newly found shortages and surpluses. All the more so if the U.S. continues to keep immigration at bay.
This will all take years, if not decades, to play out. All you can do is focus on your life. Your choices on whether to have children, or how many, are your own. In the face of existential uncertainty, all you can do is live your life. As Oliver Burkeman writes about the many problems facing us:
Yet there’s a stunning bit of good news hiding in all this grim inevitability, because if radical insecurity is just how life is, then by definition, you’re already coping with it. Do you worry that you might not have what it takes to deal with the world, if things get really uncertain in the years to come? I think you can afford to unclench a bit. With every bit of work you accomplish, every act of friendship you undertake, every instance of parenting you carry off well, you’re already proving that you do.
Outcomes in AI, robotics and modern medicine will all have a say in how we deal with demographic decline. All you can do is keep doing you.







