How much would you pay for a house that you couldn’t insure?
It’s not zero, land itself has some value. But you probably wouldn’t pay as much if you could get reasonable insurance coverage.
There’s plenty of evidence that the increase in climate-fueled natural disasters has put the insurance industry on its heels. In states like California and Florida there are signs that the market for home insurance is downright broken.
To-date Americans have been able to reliably get home insurance at reasonable premiums. If that is no longer the case going forward, problems will cascade. Mortgage issuers require home insurance, so it could drive out non-cash buyers. It could also put a halt on affordable housing focused on Americans trying to climb a rung on the home ownership ladder.*
Zoë Schlanger in The Atlantic writes about the potential doom loop that could ensue if a lack of insurance drives down home prices. Schlanger writes:
Unlike the housing bubble of the previous recession, this one won’t leave homes to gain back their value over time. The onslaught of wildfires and hurricanes likely won’t reverse course, so neither will uninsurability. In a worst-case scenario, it could lead to mortgage-market collapse: Banks won’t issue mortgages on homes that can’t get insurance coverage.
At the very least home buyers need better data on the risks that their houses face. Some homeowners will be forced to move away from areas that are too at-risk and simply uninsurable at any price.
As Kayla Scanlon notes the home insurance business is a complex one. Besides the insurers, there are state regulators, reinsurers, banks and of course home owners themselves. There are unfortunately not a lot of easy levers to pull. Scanlon writes:
Home insurers are telling regulators – “Hey, listen, the options are no insurance, underinsurance, and more expensive insurance. So buckle up.” The reason that home insurers are doing this is because they are losing a lot of money.
Mitigating the extent and impact of climate change is a multi-decade project. Homeowners, insurers and states are dealing with the problem in the here and now. It’s important to remember that a house is an asset, not necessarily an investment. Especially in light of the ongoing insurance challenges more American homeowners are facing.
*Unfortunately this problem is likely to exacerbate wealth disparities. The uber-wealthy can afford to not insure their homes. A fire or flood won’t much move the needle on their net worth. A middle or upper class person for home their home equity is a large part of wealth, not so much.







